CHRIS SUTTON TELLS MARTIN O’NEILL TO STOP EXPERIMENTING AND ALWAYS START ONE PLAYER WHO HAS BEEN CELTIC’S BEST PLAYER SO FAR THIS SEASON

Chris Sutton has sent a clear message to Martin O’Neill over Celtic’s team selection, insisting that the manager must stop experimenting with his attacking options and build his forward line around one player whose performances have made him difficult to leave out.
The former Celtic striker believes Camilo Durán must continue playing through the middle, rather than being moved out wide to accommodate other attacking options.
Sutton’s comments come amid growing scrutiny of O’Neill’s tactical decisions following Celtic’s disappointing 2-1 defeat to Celta Vigo in the Europa League on Thursday night.
The Hoops had taken the lead through Mika Baur early in the second half, but two goals from Javi Rodríguez turned the contest around and condemned Celtic to another European defeat. The result has intensified questions about the team’s consistency and the manager’s approach.
Sutton has made his feelings clear about Celtic’s attacking selection
According to a report by 67 Hail Hail in September, Sutton warned O’Neill against experimenting with his attacking options ahead of Celtic’s Old Firm clash with Rangers.
The former Celtic forward argued that Durán’s form had made him difficult to drop and that the team benefited most when he played in his natural central-striker position.
Sutton said: “I like Hogh, but Duran’s form has made him undroppable, and you get the best out of him through the middle.”
His argument was straightforward: Celtic should not disrupt a player’s effectiveness simply to accommodate another signing.
Kasper Høgh may offer the manager another attacking option, but Sutton’s position was that moving Durán away from the centre could upset the team’s balance.
The pundit’s warning raises an important question for O’Neill: should he continue searching for different attacking combinations, or should he prioritise the players who have already demonstrated their value?
Why Camilo Durán has become central to the debate
Durán’s performances have made him an important part of Celtic’s attacking discussion this season.
Sutton’s assessment was not simply about individual quality. It was also about playing footballers in positions where they can make the greatest impact.
A central striker needs to occupy defenders, create space for teammates and provide a focal point for attacks. Moving that player to the wing can change the team’s attacking structure, particularly when the alternative is a player who naturally operates in a different role.
Celtic have several attacking options available, including Høgh, Shim Mheuka, James Forrest and Sebastian Tounekti. However, having multiple options does not automatically mean the manager should change the starting combination every time a different tactical idea becomes available.
For Sutton, Durán’s form provides a compelling reason to keep things simple.
Celta Vigo defeat puts the spotlight back on O’Neill
Thursday’s defeat at Celtic Park provided another painful reminder that Celtic need greater consistency, particularly in European competition.
The Scottish champions went ahead but were unable to protect their advantage. Rodríguez equalised with a header before scoring again from outside the box just minutes later.
Celtic’s collapse after taking the lead will inevitably raise questions about defensive organisation, midfield control and the decisions made when the opposition began to gain momentum.
Although Sutton’s earlier comments about Durán were made before the latest European setback, his argument about avoiding unnecessary experimentation remains relevant to the wider discussion about Celtic’s team selection.
O’Neill must decide how to get the best out of his available players while restoring confidence to a team that has struggled to turn promising periods into victories.
Keeping a productive attacker in his strongest position could be one part of that process, but Celtic will also need improvements in other areas if they are to recover from their recent European results.
Will Martin O’Neill listen to Sutton’s warning?
O’Neill has experience managing Celtic through difficult periods, but the pressure to deliver results means every selection decision will attract attention.
The challenge is finding the right balance between tactical flexibility and consistency. Experimentation can sometimes unlock a stubborn opponent, but changing established roles can also create new problems.
Sutton’s message is that Celtic should not overcomplicate matters when a player has already shown what he can offer.
If Durán continues to perform best through the middle, O’Neill will have to weigh the benefits of keeping him there against the temptation to fit additional attacking options into the same starting eleven.
For Celtic supporters, the debate is likely to continue: should the manager stick with his most effective attacking formula, or is a different approach needed to get the team back to winning ways?
One thing is certain: after another disappointing European night, O’Neill needs his next team selection to produce a response on the pitch.




