The summer transfer window is already heating up, and Derek McInnes has sparked major debate among Scottish football fans after reportedly identifying a surprise candidate to replace Lawrence Shankland should the Hearts captain depart this summer.
While much of the attention has been focused on Scotland’s established stars, sources close to the situation suggest McInnes is considering a move for former Celtic winger Mikey Johnston, a player many supporters once labelled a flop during his time at Parkhead.
The revelation has stunned fans across the country.
Johnston, who struggled to nail down a regular starting place at Celtic despite showing flashes of brilliance, appeared destined to fade away from the Scottish football spotlight. Injuries, inconsistency, and fierce competition for places prevented him from reaching the heights many predicted when he first emerged from the Celtic academy.
However, McInnes reportedly believes the winger’s versatility, pace, and attacking instincts could make him an ideal addition to a revamped attacking unit.
What’s even more intriguing is that Johnston is allegedly being considered alongside Scotland’s £60 million-rated midfield sensation Billy Gilmour, whose stock continues to rise following a string of impressive performances at club and international level.
The possibility of both players being part of McInnes’ long-term vision has generated enormous discussion among supporters.
Many fans remain divided on Johnston.
Some believe his Celtic struggles are proof that he lacks the consistency needed to lead an ambitious side forward. Others argue that his difficult spell at Parkhead unfairly damaged his reputation and that a fresh environment could finally unlock the potential that once made him one of Scotland’s most exciting young prospects.
McInnes appears to belong firmly to the second camp.
According to reports, the experienced manager sees Johnston as a player whose best years may still be ahead of him. His ability to play across multiple attacking positions could prove crucial if Shankland departs, leaving a significant void in the squad.
Replacing Shankland, however, is no small task.
The Hearts striker has been one of the most prolific forwards in Scottish football over recent seasons, consistently delivering goals and leading from the front. Any player brought in to fill that gap would face enormous pressure from day one.
That is why McInnes is believed to be considering a broader tactical reshuffle rather than searching for a direct like-for-like replacement.
Johnston’s mobility, combined with creative support from players of Gilmour’s quality, could allow the team to spread goals throughout the squad rather than relying on a single striker.
Still, not everyone is convinced.
Social media has exploded with reactions since the rumours emerged, with many supporters questioning whether a player once deemed surplus to requirements at Celtic can truly step into such an important role.
Others have pointed out that football is full of redemption stories.
Players written off at one club often thrive elsewhere. Examples from across Europe show that confidence, coaching, and opportunity can completely transform careers.
McInnes himself has built a reputation for identifying overlooked talent and helping players revive their fortunes. That track record may explain why he is willing to gamble on a footballer many others have dismissed.
As speculation continues to grow, supporters will be watching closely to see whether these rumours develop into concrete transfer activity.
One thing is certain: if Mikey Johnston does arrive as the man chosen to help replace Lawrence Shankland, it will be one of the most talked-about transfer moves of the summer.
The former Celtic winger may have been labelled a flop by critics, but Derek McInnes appears convinced that the story is far from over.
And if he’s right, Scottish football could be about to witness one of its most unexpected redemption arcs.